Andrés Duany Responds to Critics ≡
Last week’s New York Times Magazine featured an
article by Jim Lewis on Gulf Coast reconstruction, which contained some criticism of the way urban planners
have engaged with local and federal officials. The planners brought in by the commision directing the rebuilding
in Biloxi Mississippi are proponents of New Urbanism, which advocates for
denser, more pedestrian-friendly growth. Some of the problems he pointed out were legitimate; however, at times
he over-salted the argument by implying a certain fanaticism of the philosophy’s proponents. Dismissing people
as “fanatical” is the coarsest form of argument as it doesn’t address or engage them in anyway. Someone else at
the Times must have noticed, because the more balanced article referenced above was published a few days later.
» Posted: Thursday, May 25, 2006
